MedPay vs PIP: A Field-by-Field Comparison with State Rules
Direct answer
MedPay is a small first-party medical coverage that pays reasonable medical and funeral expenses for the insured and passengers after a crash, regardless of fault. PIP is broader: it pays medical bills plus lost wages, replacement services, and (in most no-fault states) funeral costs, also regardless of fault. PIP is mandatory in roughly a dozen no-fault states; MedPay is optional almost everywhere it is sold.12
The quick answer
- MedPay covers medical bills only, usually without a deductible, usually optional.2
- PIP covers medical bills plus lost wages and other economic loss, with state-specific limits.1
- Neither depends on fault. Both are first-party coverages that pay your own household regardless of who caused the crash.1
- PIP is mandatory in no-fault states. Florida, Michigan, New York, New Jersey, Utah, Massachusetts, Minnesota, North Dakota, Hawaii, Kansas. Pennsylvania and Kentucky are choice no-fault; the District of Columbia offers PIP as an add-on.7
Field-by-field comparison
For the standalone definitions, see our medical payments (MedPay) coverage and personal injury protection (PIP) coverage guides.
| Category | MedPay | PIP |
|---|---|---|
| Medical bills from a crash | Yes. Reasonable medical and dental expenses for the insured and passengers. | Yes. Typically broader than MedPay, with a defined percentage of medical expenses up to the policy limit.1 |
| Lost wages | No. | Yes. PIP typically pays a defined percentage of lost earnings up to a weekly or policy cap (for example, Florida pays 60 percent of lost wages under its PIP statute).3 |
| Funeral or burial costs | Limited. Some MedPay forms include a small funeral expense sublimit. | Yes. Funeral and burial expenses are generally covered up to a stated amount.1 |
| Replacement services (childcare, housekeeping) during recovery | No. | Yes, in most no-fault states. Specific daily limits apply (see Florida and New York PIP statutes).4 |
| Passenger coverage | Yes. Covers passengers in the insured vehicle. | Yes. Covers the named insured, resident family members, and passengers; details vary by state.1 |
| Fault dependency | No. First-party; pays regardless of fault. | No. First-party; pays regardless of fault. That is the core design of no-fault systems.1 |
| Deductible or copay | Usually none. | Varies by state. Several no-fault states let the insured select a deductible or copay (for example, Florida allows a deductible on PIP; Michigan allows a coordination-of-benefits election with health insurance).5 |
| Interaction with health insurance | Typically pays before health insurance for crash-related bills, which is why consumers with high-deductible plans often add it. | Primary in most no-fault states, though Michigan permits coordination of benefits with health insurance in exchange for a reduced premium.5 |
| Pedestrian or cyclist struck by the insured vehicle | Usually no (MedPay covers the insured and occupants). | Yes, in several no-fault states. Pedestrians and cyclists struck by an insured vehicle collect PIP from that vehicle's policy under state law.4 |
| State availability | Optional in most states. | Mandatory in no-fault states (list below); optional in several add-on states; not sold in true tort states.7 |
PIP-mandatory and PIP-optional states
PIP as a mandatory coverage is tied to a state's no-fault system, which limits lawsuits for injury below a verbal or monetary threshold. States with mandatory PIP are either pure no-fault (lawsuits allowed only above a threshold) or modified no-fault. Several states offer PIP as an add-on to a tort system without a lawsuit threshold.
| State | PIP status | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| Florida | Mandatory no-fault, PIP required. | Fla. Stat. section 627.736 |
| Michigan | Mandatory no-fault, PIP required with tiered medical limit options after 2019 reform. | MCL 500.3101 et seq. |
| New York | Mandatory no-fault, PIP (Basic Economic Loss) required. | NY Ins. Law section 5102; 11 NYCRR Part 65 |
| New Jersey | Modified no-fault, PIP required on standard and basic policies. | N.J.S.A. 39:6A-4 |
| Pennsylvania | Choice no-fault, limited tort or full tort election; PIP required at a minimum limit. | 75 Pa. C.S. section 1711 |
| Utah | Mandatory no-fault, PIP required. | Utah Code section 31A-22-307 |
| Massachusetts | Mandatory no-fault, PIP required. | M.G.L. ch. 90, section 34A; 34M |
| Minnesota | Mandatory no-fault, PIP required. | Minn. Stat. section 65B.44 |
| North Dakota | Mandatory no-fault, PIP required. | N.D.C.C. section 26.1-41 |
| Hawaii | Mandatory no-fault, PIP required. | HRS section 431:10C-103.5 |
| Kansas | Mandatory no-fault, PIP required. | K.S.A. section 40-3103 |
| Kentucky | Choice no-fault; drivers can reject tort limitations in writing. PIP (Basic Reparation Benefits) required unless rejected. | KRS section 304.39-020 |
| District of Columbia | Add-on PIP: PIP available as an optional benefit; DC is a tort state with an election option. | D.C. Code section 31-2404 |
Verbal threshold states (New York, Michigan, Florida, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Hawaii) require an injury of a defined severity before a lawsuit is allowed. Monetary threshold states set a dollar amount of medical bills (or similar) as the trigger. The threshold rule changes how aggressively PIP matters at the margin, because below the threshold PIP is the consumer's only recovery.1
Worked example: same crash, two states
Hypothetical. You are rear-ended at a red light. Your medical bills total $6,000. You miss two weeks of work, losing roughly $2,400 in wages. Your policy carries a $5,000 MedPay limit (if MedPay) or a $10,000 PIP limit (if PIP). Fault lies with the other driver.
MedPay state. MedPay pays up to its $5,000 limit toward the medical bills, with no deductible. The remaining $1,000 of medical and the $2,400 in lost wages are not covered by MedPay. You typically pursue the at-fault driver's liability coverage or your underinsured motorist coverage for the balance.
PIP state (illustrative Florida numbers). Florida PIP pays 80 percent of reasonable medical expenses and 60 percent of lost wages up to the policy limit under Fla. Stat. section 627.736.3 On these facts, PIP covers roughly $4,800 of medical and roughly $1,440 of lost wages, up to the $10,000 policy limit. Remaining amounts are pursued through other coverages or against the at-fault driver, subject to the state's tort threshold. Dollar figures are illustrative, not drawn from any carrier filing.
What changes the answer
- Your state. No-fault status, PIP mandate, lawsuit threshold, and PIP limit floor are all set by state statute. The Florida PIP page and New Jersey auto page document the two of the strictest no-fault systems in detail.
- Policy form election. New Jersey offers a Basic Policy and a Standard Policy with different PIP limits. Pennsylvania and Kentucky let you elect full or limited tort, which changes what PIP does for you.
- Coordination with health insurance. Michigan uniquely lets the insured coordinate PIP with health insurance in exchange for a reduced auto premium; most states do not. MedPay is almost always primary for the covered crash-related bills.5
- Deductible election. Several states allow a PIP deductible or copay. MedPay almost always has no deductible. If you are shopping, compare apples to apples.
Exceptions and edge cases
- Michigan 2019 reform. Michigan drivers can now choose from tiered PIP medical limits (including lower limits and a limited no-fault option for Medicare and qualifying health plans). This is unique within the no-fault family.5
- Pedestrians and cyclists. In most no-fault states, a pedestrian or cyclist struck by a covered vehicle recovers under that vehicle's PIP. MedPay typically does not reach a non-occupant.
- Non-owned vehicles. Both coverages generally follow the insured person (as named insured or resident family member) in a non-owned vehicle, but the specifics vary by policy form and by state statute. Read the declarations page.
- Subrogation and reimbursement. Some MedPay provisions let the carrier recover from a third-party liability settlement; some do not. PIP in no-fault states follows statutory rules on subrogation and offset.
- Rejection in writing. Kentucky drivers can reject the tort limitation in writing, which changes the role PIP plays in their claim.
Related questions
- How much car insurance do I need?
- What happens if an uninsured driver hits me?
- Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage
- Liability coverage
Checking your state's rules? Quote the required PIP or MedPay with a couple of carriers to see the premium delta before you choose.
Compare car insurance quotesYesWeSure may receive compensation when readers use quote-comparison links. See our advertiser disclosure and editorial standards.
Sources
- Insurance Information Institute: Background on no-fault auto insurance. Describes PIP as a first-party coverage that pays medical bills, lost wages, replacement services, and funeral costs regardless of fault; and MedPay as a smaller first-party medical coverage available in most states. (Insurance Information Institute)
- Insurance Information Institute: What is medical payments coverage? Explains that MedPay pays reasonable medical and funeral expenses for the insured and passengers regardless of fault, is typically offered without a deductible, and is optional in most states. (Insurance Information Institute)
- Florida Statutes section 627.736, Required personal injury protection benefits. Establishes mandatory PIP in Florida, including 80 percent of reasonable medical expenses and 60 percent of lost wages up to the policy limit. (Florida Legislature)
- New York Insurance Law section 5102 and 11 NYCRR Part 65 (Regulation 68). Defines Basic Economic Loss and mandatory no-fault (PIP) benefits in New York, including medical, lost earnings, and other reasonable and necessary expenses. (New York Department of Financial Services)
- Michigan Compiled Laws section 500.3101 et seq. (the Michigan No-Fault Act). Requires personal injury protection on registered vehicles; 2019 reforms created tiered PIP medical limit options. (Michigan Legislature)
- New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance: Automobile Insurance Buyer's Guide. New Jersey is a modified no-fault state with mandatory PIP; the standard policy offers Basic and Standard forms with different PIP limits. (New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance)
- NAIC: A Consumer's Guide to Auto Insurance. Describes MedPay and PIP as first-party coverages, distinguishes no-fault states, and lists optional and mandatory status by category. (National Association of Insurance Commissioners)
State PIP rules, limits, and thresholds are set by statute and regulation and change over time. Statutes cited (Fla. Stat. section 627.736; NY Ins. Law section 5102; MCL 500.3101; N.J.S.A. 39:6A-4; and others) are the controlling text in each state; confirm the current version with the state DOI before making a coverage decision. Dollar figures in the worked example are illustrative only, not drawn from any carrier filing. Last reviewed .